SSI logo

The Truth About License Plate Recognition Technology

Is there a difference between license plate cameras and license plate recognition systems? Yes, there is, according to SSI blogger Bob Grossman.



By ·

After numerous questions about the merits and drawbacks of cameras designed to capture images of the license plates of vehicles entering and exiting a property, I wanted to put something together to clarify the two approaches to this application. These cameras are often referred to interchangeably as “license plate cameras” and “license plate readers”. In fact, these terms are not interchangeable and refer to two completely different types of systems, albeit with some functional overlap.

License plate cameras are video cameras that allow for real-time and recorded video of vehicles entering through the associated lanes. While model selection can vary depending on the application, these are “standard” cameras that, depending on lighting, weather conditions, and vehicle speed, etc., usually (but not always) provide the operator with the ability to view and recognize the image of a license plate and manually log the number. They also often capture information on the vehicle (make, model, color, condition) and sometimes the occupants, depending on placement and environmental conditions.

License plate readers are specialized cameras designed to capture tag numbers off of license plates. With the associated software (these are sold as systems), they attempt to automatically read and record a list of license plate numbers in an alphanumeric data format. They do not capture images of the vehicle, and are designed for this one specific purpose. They either provide this information in an Excel type spreadsheet format for manual comparison, or require integration into third-party databases that are only available to law enforcement agencies. When integrated, the systems are designed to “flag” a vehicle to an operator or via a printout when a tag matches one in the database. Together with the software, these are commonly referred to as license plate recognition systems.

A license plate recognition system is far more costly than a camera capturing an image, and the database integration usually incurs recurring fees. These databases are not generally searchable, limiting the value of these systems for forensic examination of data to determine patterns and threats. They are not infallible, and rarely work as well once installed as the demos suggest. According to numerous sources, their primary purpose seems to be as a revenue generation system, allowing the automatic generation of lists that can be utilized by the local police jurisdiction to issue a traffic summons where appropriate.

There are also privacy concerns regarding such systems, particularly concerning the retention and disposition of the data collected by these systems. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is pursuing legal action on a number of fronts and the ultimate legality and usefulness of this equipment appears likely to be further defined and refined.

In summary, these two types of systems differ widely in functionality, usefulness, and cost (roughly ten to twenty times the cost for a standalone permanently mounted license plate recognition system versus a high-end high resolution IP camera).  If we are asked to specify them for a law enforcement agency affiliated with a client, we would require significant input from the agency to ensure that they understand the limitations of such systems and managing their expectations. While we continue to stay on top of this technology, I saw several of these systems in action at the security industry trade show ISC West 2014 in Las Vegas and my opinion has not changed. In fact, during one demo, the operator clicked on a license plate number that had been recognized and it brought up a video image of a plate that was not the same as the listed number. And that was based on demo footage, not real world conditions.

Some information and assessment of the operation of these systems, based on personal experience, was provided by Lieutenant Paul Sorrentino, Support Division Commander at the Township of Hamilton Police Department in New Jersey.


Article Topics
Video Surveillance · Blogs · License Plate Readers · License Plate Recognition · All Topics

About the Author
Bob Grossman
Bob Grossman has held positions in all areas of the security industry — giving him plenty of opportunity to learn from his mistakes! He has spent time as an end user, responsible for security, surveillance and low-voltage electronics at Bally’s Park Place, a major Atlantic City casino. As a senior project manager for Sensormatic Electronics’ Enterprise Accounts group, he learned first-hand the difficulty in translating ideas into reality while staying on schedule and under budget. He has worked for both Vicon Industries (as vice president of Customer and Technical Services) and American Dynamics/Tyco Safety Products (as director of Product Line Management), with responsibilities that included pre- and post-sales support, project design, product line management, customer service and sales. Bob has authored several articles for SECURITY SALES & INTEGRATION and other publications and has spoken at numerous industry events both internationally and in the United State. Currently the founder and president of R. Grossman and Associates, a consulting firm, he divides his time between project-based work for large integrated systems and product consulting for a variety of cutting-edge manufacturers.
Contact Bob Grossman: rdgrossman@tech-answers.com
View More by Bob Grossman
License Plate Readers


Latest Download
The industry-wide migration to IP video surveillance over the last few…
Trending


SPONSORED LINKS


Don't miss out! Subscribe to Security Sales & Integration magazine today. - Security Sales & Integration

EDITOR'S CHOICE