Security Sales and Integration Magazine

Addressing Video Surveillance Privacy Concerns

By Steve Payne | February 15, 2011 | Comments (2) | Post a comment

Recently in the news, there was an uproar from the ACLU about Chicago's desire to increase the number of video security cameras in use throughout the city. While I think part of the ACLU's concern comes from a misunderstanding of the actual state of the technology, as well as a perception of the way Chicago does business, it still opens up some interesting questions about the increasing use of video surveillance systems.

Privacy is now, and has always been, a concern for our industry. There are obvious places where cameras can't go like bathrooms and such, and without specific agreements, a city can't put its cameras into a private business or residence. For cameras mounted on city streets, the situation is not so clear.

Different technologies have been developed over time to ensure, as much as possible, the privacy of the subjects in front of cameras. Several years ago, window blanking was implemented on pan/tilt/zoom (p/t/z) cameras as a way to obscure sections in view of a camera. This became a mandatory feature on p/t/z cameras in some applications, one example being the UK. 

Some megapixel cameras now are also offering some form of window blanking feature. The question is does it go far enough? Anyone with administrative access to the camera can turn this off, and we all know how many people change the admin password, right?

We need to make sure that the push for privacy doesn't go so far that it makes video technology unusable, but we also need to be somewhat sensitive to the average citizen's concerns. Generally this is a function of education, but that message doesn't always get out to the crowds.

What new technologies are you seeing out there that can help add privacy to a system? Let me know in the comments section below what has worked for you. 

 

Review / Comment


Steve--Very important article and question. This is obviously a provocative subject. Have you read about the company discussed in this article: http://www.securitymanagement.com/news/big-brother-sleeps-during-day-brookline-awakes-night-falls-008044 ...it's more than just privacy, the eyelids on the cameras are the ultimate privacy guarantee – even if someone with authority logs onto the system, all they would see is the inside of the eyelids – and once the eyelids are open it is crystal clear to the public that they are being monitored.
Jeff Benanto
February 23, 2011
was this review helpful?
Jeff, thanks for the reply. I hadn't seen that solution. That's very unique. I know more of these kinds of things will come about as more citywide systems are implemented. Another solution I have heard about is using thermal, although it's very cost prohibitive right now. But a thermal image would show behaviors and activities, but not identify anyone. Interesting thoughts.
Steve
February 25, 2011
was this review helpful?

Other Security Blog Posts

Enterprising Solutions | May 2, 2012

Back to the Basics of Camera Placement

While it’s true that modern cameras can often get you good images under lousy conditions, improving conditions usually improves the image quality dramatically. In that spirit, here are a few camera placement tips that we frequently see overlooked.

Central Station Corner | April 26, 2012

Layering Security Services Helps Meet Customer Needs

As security professionals, we strive to provide the best possible electronic security solutions for our clients that will meet their unique lifestyles or logistics of their business. This element should always remain to be our focus as we survey a potential or existing customer’s premise.

Value-Added Security | April 25, 2012

Tips for Designing Value-Based Solutions

In this blog, Paul Boucherle discusses what integrators must do to design the best solutions for end users.

Under Surveillance | April 19, 2012

Why the Most Successful Managers Support Mentoring

Are you currently mentoring your employees? SSI Managing Editor Rodney Bosch offers some insight on why mentoring your workers is essential to improving your business.

Laying Down the Law | April 16, 2012

Addressing an Alarm Company’s Name Change in Contracts

Ken Kirschenbaum advises readers on how to address changes in contracts after modifying the company's name..

Author Bios
Steve Payne
Steve Payne

Steve Payne, who has been MCSE and CCNA certified, has spent more than 15 years in the security, IP networking and law enforcement industries, holding positions ranging from end user to manufacturer and everything in between. Steve is an independent consultant and owner of Convergence Consulting, an IP and security solutions consulting firm. He can be reached at [email protected].