Security Sales and Integration Magazine

Fire/Life Safety

Fire Victim Blames Alarm Company for Defective System

December 06, 2011 | Comments (7) | Post a comment
Claiming that her Vivint alam system did not alert to warn her family of a fire set off in herClaiming that her Vivint alam system did not alert to warn her family of a fire set off in her garage, Regina Martinez posted this sign on her lawn. After she posted an image of the sign on Facebook, she finally heard from the alarm company, according to her claim. Screenshot: KMOV

By Ashley Willis

ST. PETERS, Mo. — A family that claims their fire alarm did not sound during a fire is blaming the alarm company that installed the system, citing that the system did not work.

Regina Martinez is currently rebuilding her home after a Nov. 1 fire damaged it, reports KMOV.com. During the incident, Martinez claims that her Vivint system did not go off; rather, a neighbor notified her that her home was on fire.

Additionally, Martinez maintains that despite contacting Vivint (formerly APX Alarm), she didn't hear back from the company until she posted a sign on her lawn calling out the company for negligence, and posted the image on Facebook.

However, Vivint spokesperson Lisa Davis tells SSI that the installed system was not faulty.

"She did have a Vivint system in her home, but it was a basic system that came with a single smoke and heat detector," she says. "That one device was at the far end of her home from where the fire started, which was in the garage."

Martinez, a Vivint customer for about a year, had other smoke detectors in the home that weren't connected to the Vivint system. A report from the fire department said that a detector near the garage did trigger, Davis says.

"It wasn't connected to a monitoring station, so it just went off as an alarm," she says. "Thankfully, her neighbor heard it and everybody got out safely."

Although the company maintains that their system wasn't defective, Vivint refunded the $1,144.74 Martinez spent on the fire alarm.

"Our hearts definitely go out to her," Davis says. "We're still in conversation with her, and we've sent out our technicians to see if there is anything we can do to help her that's within our ability to do so."

So, what can alarm companies do to prevent a similar incident from happening to them? Davis says it is important to remind consumers to double check to make sure all home automation/security devices are connected to the control panel.

"It's really important that customers are well informed about the security systems," she says. "We always recommend that customers have a professional evaluate their homes to see what type of systems work best. At the same time, alarm companies need to remind customers that they have a real responsibility as well. We can do a lot on our end, but we also need their help in making sure that everything is in place to keep their homes and families safe."

Ashley Willis is associate editor for SECURITY SALES & INTEGRATION. She can be reached at (310) 533-2419.


Review / Comment


national fire code states that there will be at least one smoke detector on each floor, one outside of all sleeping areas, as well as one in each sleeping area.....if there was one smoke detector on this system, sounds like it didn't meet code.
Rick
December 8, 2011
was this review helpful?
Yes, but it does not state that they all have to be connected to a monitored system or not. State Farm Insurance states that in order to receive a discount on your homeowner's for an alarm system, all you must have is ONE monitored smoke detector or a burglary system. It's no wonder that's what people elect to do a lot of the time.
Jeff
December 8, 2011
was this review helpful?
I see no blame in the security company here. one smoke is not a fire system and just like every other install, I am sure it wasn't sold as one. They didn't even have it monitored so how can the alarm company be responsible for anything. I wouldn't have gave the money back, yes I feel bad for them but the system didn't start the fire so it isn't the alarm companies responsibilty. I would have sued them for the signs and facebook pages.
Westley
December 8, 2011
was this review helpful?
Would love to have the correct full story updated. Vivints fire alarm/siren DID go off and the Captain is the one who eventually turned it off. Vivint never notified the fire/police/911/me of the incident! Not even after the power went off and the wireless system should have notified someone again. Double failure to do what I paid them to do. Vivint does not mention when they took the system over from ADT the cut the wires to the other fire alarms downstairs that were once all connected to the system and placed them back up into the ceiling to 'appear' as though they were working and connected - instead of taking it down and capping it. Vivint did not want to talk to me about this fire until this photo went up on facebook. Please give me a call if you would like the proof and to hear how Vivints customer service has been handling this case aka our family.
Gina Martinez
December 12, 2011
was this review helpful?
Westley, yes it was sold as one. And they have not given me one penny. Westley, sue me for what THE TRUTH? Rick, I did have 6 other alarms in the house as well.
Gina Martinez
December 12, 2011
was this review helpful?
Does the basic system come with monitoring of all windows and doors? Also with fire alarms? Wireless backup in case the wires/power was cut to my home? Two key pads? Just curious because I was told this was not a basic package? So how did it now become basic? And were we supposed to pull down all smoke alarms in the house and look at the wiring to see if they had been cut by your installer? Ms. Davis, your tech said the system was in working order, even with just the one working alarm and the other for just decoration.
Gina Martinez
December 12, 2011
was this review helpful?
And Westley, I added a link to my facebook for this story as well. Truth and Accountability!
Gina Martinez
December 12, 2011
was this review helpful?

Other Recent News

May 22, 2012

Eaton to Purchase Cooper Industries for $11.8B

Eaton Corp., a diversified industrial manufacturer, announced this week it has agreed to purchase Cooper Industries for $11.8 billion.

May 15, 2012

NFPA Seeks Code Enforcers for Technical Committees

The National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) has launched a recruitment campaign to increase the number of code enforcers participating on its technical committees.

April 24, 2012

Holland Township (Mich.) to Fine Offenders for False Fire Alarms

The Board of Trustees here approved a false fire alarm ordinance that will require repeat offenders to pay $750 for each false alarm.

April 10, 2012

SIA Supports Reintroduced Residential CO Poisoning Prevention Act

The Security Industry Association (SIA), in conjunction with several other groups, is supporting bipartisan legislation reintroduced by Congressman Jim Matheson (D-Utah) and Congressman Charlie Bass (R-N.H.) to increase the use of life-saving residential carbon monoxide (CO) alarms.

March 22, 2012

NICET Completes Transition to Computer-Based Test

The National Training Center (NTC) has completed the transition to computer-based testing (CBT) for NICET Fire Alarm exams.

Sign up for the eControl Panel

env Sign up here to receive current news and industry updates delivered right to your inbox.