Big Growth Forecast for PIAM Systems Despite Current Miniscule Adoption
IHS Markit projects global revenues for PIAM systems will more than triple by 2021, thereby posing a potential threat to access control manufacturers.
DENVER — Global market revenues for physical identity access management (PIAM) systems, excluding Asia Pacific and Africa, amounted to a paltry $136 million in 2016, according to new research by IHS Markit. However, the market is forecast to grow rapidly to nearly $500 million by 2021.
The expected rise in PIAM systems has IHS pondering if the technology is a threat to access control equipment manufacturers. A PIAM system’s ability to link together and manage multiple brands of access control hardware essentially undermines the allure of some large manufacturers’ offerings, writes Jim Dearing, senior analyst, access control and fire, IHS Markit.
“One of the unique selling points that large multinational access control suppliers tout is the fact that they can offer some of the functionality of a PIAM system across an enterprise installation,” he says. “For example, central management of credentials and active directory integration. The catch is that the enterprise has to exclusively adopt that supplier’s brand.”
PIAM systems essentially add a decision-making identity management layer on top of access control systems, Dearing writes. This is done by changing the authoritative decision-making database or location to a higher authority like an active directory or an identity and access management (IAM) system. This means the system is able to deploy identities (card holders) and credentials (cards) as well as assign access rights into one or more vendor-independent physical access control systems.
Because PIAM makes it easy to control multiple brands of equipment across a single installation, it also makes it easier for the end user to change the access control equipment over time by using the PIAM to ease the transition. Historically, suppliers have always fought extremely hard for “greenfield projects.”
“The first access control brand deployed had a huge advantage over the competition because the easiest way to expand that system later on was to buy the same brand again,” Dearing says. “PIAM software, however, potentially eliminates this advantage for manufacturers.”
If the adoption of PIAM systems continues to grow as expected, larger suppliers may begin to see their grip on high-value projects from the transportation, corporate enterprise and utilities sectors weaken, Dearing suggests, especially considering that these high-value projects seem to be the earliest adopters of PIAM.
For example, IHS Markit estimates that the number of transportation sector access control projects that include some form of PIAM system will quadruple during the next five years. End users from these industries are increasingly seeing the benefits of being able to automate credential management and comply with legislation. Additionally, they possess budgets large enough to afford implementing such a system.
Barriers to Wider Adoption
There are still a number of barriers that PIAM providers must overcome before true mass market adoption occurs. According to IHS, only 2% of all commercial access control projects included some form of PIAM system in 2016. Complexity remains the primary hurdle to wide PIAM system implementation.
Early adopters often have a clear picture of what they would like the system to do. The problems arise when they start to realize that their pre-existing physical and logical security infrastructure is not able to meet their own requirements. This usually comes in one of two forms: access control hardware limitations or weaknesses in their corporate governance and workflows. Both result in delays to PIAM system implementation.
“Due to their complexity, PIAM solutions currently require large commissioning and design efforts, not only initially but also post-implementation due to system maintenance needs,” Dearing says. “This means there is a cost involved for the entire lifecycle that the system is in place. These costs and the lengthy implementation process present a huge barrier to adoption in smaller projects.”
Even for larger projects, other system implementation factors continue to stifle adoption. Installing and servicing PIAM software requires a high level of collaboration and communication between the enterprise’s physical security and IT departments. Historically these two departments tend to disagree on where the equilibrium lies for the conventional “security versus convenience” balancing act that every company faces. Working on a PIAM system together is often no different.
Despite various barriers and the threat of increased competition, PIAM also presents a significant opportunity for suppliers of physical access control systems. The addition of logical integration adds a variety of unique selling points to a standard access control system offering, allowing the supplier to become more competitive.
Additionally, if a large number of suppliers add some form of logical integration to their offerings, it may help to slow market adoption of full PIAM systems. It is unlikely that a particularly cost-sensitive end user would opt for a bespoke solution when they are already getting some level of logical integration from the physical security manufacturer.
Furthermore, a traditional supplier that fully commits to developing its logical integration capabilities may be also able to provide a true “off-the-shelf” solution. This would be more affordable than the current PIAM systems on the market and would have the potential to drive greater adoption in small- and medium-sized enterprise (SME) projects.
Security Is Our Business, Too
For professionals who recommend, buy and install all types of electronic security equipment, a free subscription to Security Sales & Integration is like having a consultant on call. You’ll find an ideal balance of technology and business coverage, with installation tips and techniques for products and updates on how to add sales to your bottom line.
A free subscription to the #1 resource for the residential and commercial security industry will prove to be invaluable. Subscribe today!