How to Choose the Right Classroom Lockdown Technology for Your School
When searching for classroom security solutions, schools must ensure the technology is effective, as well as easy to implement and to use.
There are few topics in the news these days that are more important or emotionally charged than classroom and school security.
This topic has generated a plethora of complex solutions. However, researched more thoroughly, many of the resultant system designs are certainly not for the untrained and may result in schools resembling a prison more than an educational institution. Many of these solutions are ultimately halted due to perpetual installer dependence and exorbitant funding requirements.
Where to Begin
That said, it is worthwhile to learn and seek out the best plans from professionals, as well as those with the unfortunate life experiences surviving the all too well-known school attacks across the country.
The best place to start might be the nationally recognized and Security Industry Association (SIA) -supported Partner Alliance for Safer Schools (PASS) guidelines. They offer the most comprehensive, end-to-end security analysis and design tool for protecting grade-school campuses (see the PASS overview diagram here) and they offer it free to schools!
While the guidance, plans, specifications, and general consultation are free, the products are not and following such best practices is a long-term commitment, usually covering many budget cycles. While encouraged, it is not always practical. Compromise is usually the resulting outcome.
Common-Sense 1st Steps to Bolstering Classroom Security
The staff and budget required to digest and implement the balance of the PASS recommendations may be overwhelming and have unfortunately dissuaded smaller campuses such as private schools from the attempt at all. This typically results in calls to local security vendors, who may offer the more well publicized video surveillance and perimeter access control products as their panacea, while, unfortunately, missing the most effective mitigation solution – swapping out their brass key classroom locks with electronic locks.
Beyond the obvious perimeter door-locking policy and installation of a single entry-point card access and visitor entrance, PASS and several state education authorities have now published specifications for classroom security locks.
Notably, these are the most effective and the lowest-cost security dollars a school can spend. Additionally, they can also be the simplest to implement and maintain, especially since every classroom door needs a door lock anyway.
Classroom vs. Global Lockdown During a Crisis
“There has never been an event in which an active shooter breached a locked classroom door,” a safety commission convened after the Newtown Sandy Hook School massacre pointed out in 2015, with recent analysis showing that this statement remains true today.
Practically, but surprisingly not widely discussed, the classrooms most immediately in need of locking down are those in most immediate danger – in the closest proximity to the initiating and unfolding event. Thus, they must be given the tools to provide for their individual lockdown and safety.
If so provided, then as the event progresses throughout a facility, each classroom can be self-secured.
How Tech Has Been Used During School Lockdowns
It is important to back up for a moment and realize that everything schools have been taught to this point is antithetical to this best practice. The term “global lockdown” is traditionally discussed as the response to an active shooter, but what that actually means is that an administrator must first hear of the emergency in order for the school-wide annunciation to begin.
Unfortunately, this reveals many impediments to a safe result for the staff and students under threat. Additionally, it the administrator is usually not the person closest to the event, and once they hear about it, they must locate the computer with access to the security software, open the software and then must locate and press the global lockdown button.
How quickly or even likely is this to happen, and will first responders only be notified from a possibly unverifiable caller?
The next possibility is that one or more administrators can wear a clicker, or a button can be wired into each classroom, so that an emergency notification can be received by an administrator and/or first responder more quickly. However, these costly options still do not result in the door being locked down, which must be performed by a separate action.
Now we must address the secondary actions and the problems inherent in a “global” lockdown-centric response, resulting from the security system software responding to a “lockdown” event initiated from a classroom or elsewhere on the school grounds.
The signal from a classroom or worn panic button will rely on some amount of IT and network gateways and switches, each of which must have 100% up-time and sufficient battery back-up to support such an event through a power loss or weather event.
Unfortunately, switches regularly are reconfigured or moved, and back-up power is typically in the 15 to 30 minute range, if at all. So, that is not the perfect life-safety dependency.
Even if the global lockdown is finally initiated, an important predicament must now be addressed of who will be orphaned/stranded in the hallways when all the doors are automatically locked down.
Electronic Locks Can Be Effective in Classroom Security
So let us return to the initial scenario we discussed, wherein those nearest the event and in harm’s way will first hear about it and will have but one thing to do – lockdown their own door.
By selecting the best electronic lock available for each classroom door, this lockdown initiation of the first and closest classrooms should allow for a notification to electronically reach the security software, transmitting out to the necessary administrators and even first responders, the classroom and initiator’s name and number, all without the reliance on IT infrastructure.
Further, within the classroom, the lock should have the means to be locked down in multiple ways, as selected by the school security team, including by a button on the lock, a more tamper-proof lever and button combination action, and from across the room with a mobile phone-based button.
There is one more important distinction a school should understand when selecting a lockdown solution: The locks must not simply bar free entry, but they must also automatically revoke the rights of any previously valid card, keychain for or mobile key, which could otherwise be taken off of a teacher or administrator in the hallway by the intruder and used to gain entry to supposedly secured doors.
In conjunction with a key-use reporting mechanism in the lock, which will keep brass keys off of keychains altogether, this is the only fool-proof way to put safety and security in the hands of those who need it quickest, while also, though secondarily, providing administrative and first responder support.
Rob Schorr is the solutions architect and Paul Hevesy is the vice president of business development for Proxess.
The original version of this post appeared on SSI’s sister site, CampusSafety.com.
If you enjoyed this article and want to receive more valuable industry content like this, click here to sign up for our FREE digital newsletters!
Security Is Our Business, Too
For professionals who recommend, buy and install all types of electronic security equipment, a free subscription to Commercial Integrator + Security Sales & Integration is like having a consultant on call. You’ll find an ideal balance of technology and business coverage, with installation tips and techniques for products and updates on how to add to your bottom line.
A FREE subscription to the top resource for security and integration industry will prove to be invaluable.